The 10 Best Costco Pickles (Ultimate Guide + FAQs)

Have you ever been in the aisle at Costco and wondered which pickles to buy? Well, look no further!

With a variety of flavors, textures, and sizes, you can find exactly what you need for your next meal or snack.

This comprehensive guide will tell you all about the best pickles you can buy at Costco.

Whether you’re looking for a spicy kick or just a classic dill spear, this guide has everything you need to know about the top-rated pickles at Costco.

Let’s take a look at the best pickles available at Costco.

What Are The Best Costco Pickles?

Costco pickles have the potential to transform your meal from regular to memorable.

Whether you’re buying dill chips for a classic burger, sweet chunks for a sandwich, or tangy pickle spears for an elevated cheese plate, Costco’s selection of pickles can make all the difference.

But how do you know which type is best? With so many varieties on store shelves, it can be hard to choose one that will elevate everyday meals and snacks.

In this guide, we’ll discuss why choosing quality pickles matters and reveal our top picks of Costco-exclusive brands so you can take your cooking game up a notch!

Grillo’s Pickles Italian Dill Spears – 52 oz

If you’re looking for a classic dill pickle with an Italian twist, Grillo’s has got you covered.

grillo's pickles italian dill spears
Grillo’s Pickles Italian Dill Spears is a unique delicacy that has earned a respected place in the pickle world.

They use only fresh cucumbers and high-quality ingredients to make their signature Italian Dill Spears that are sure to please any dill lover.

These spears are packed with garlic and spices that add depth and complexity to their flavor profile. The crunchy texture will have you coming back for more!

Not only are they crunchy and delicious, but they also come in a big 52-ounce jar that will last you for weeks (or days if you eat them as quickly as we do).

Princess Pickled Asparagus – 2 X 33 oz

For those of us who like something a little more unique than classic dills, Princess Pickled Asparagus is definitely worth checking out.

princess pickled asparagus
Princess Pickled Asparagus is a unique gourmet product that will delight even the most discerning palates.

This jar comes with two 33-ounce jars of asparagus spears that have been soaked in brine and spices for added flavor.

These asparagus spears are crispy, tart, and slightly sweet. Plus, the long spears provide plenty of texture to any dish.

They’re great on their own or as part of a salad or sandwich—and since there are two jars in one package, there’s plenty to go around! 

Nalley Pickles Whole Baby Dill – 2/33.8 oz

If you’re looking for something smaller than the Grillo’s or Princess jars, Nalley has got you covered with their Whole Baby Dill pickles.

nalley pickles whole baby dill
Nalley Pickles Whole Baby Dill provides health-conscious snackers with a mouthwatering blend of homemade dill pickle taste.

These tiny cucumber slices come in two 33.8-ounce jars that are fantastic for snacking on the go or serving up at parties and get-togethers—just don’t forget to bring extra napkins!

These tiny baby dill pickles from Nalley pack a big taste in every bite. They have just the right amount of tartness that gives them their signature flavor without overpowering your tastebuds.

Add them to your burgers or sandwiches for an extra crunch and flavor boost!

Taste Of The South Fried Pickle Ranch Dip – 32 oz

If fried pickles are more your style, then Taste Of The South has what you need with their Fried Pickle Ranch Dip.

taste of the south fried pickle ranch dip
The South Fried Pickle Ranch Dip from Taste of the South is a unique combination of flavors you must taste to believe.

This 32-ounce tub contains a creamy ranch sauce that is perfectly seasoned and packed full of crunchy fried pickles—it goes great with chips or crackers and is sure to be a hit at any gathering!

This dip is a must-have at any gathering! Creamy ranch mixed with crunchy fried pickles is a match made in heaven. It also makes a great topping on salads or burgers if you want to get creative in the kitchen!

Mama Lil’s Mildly Spicy Peppers – 26.5 oz

If you like it hot (but not too hot), Mama Lil’s Mildly Spicy Peppers are sure to hit the spot.

mama lil's mildy spicy peppers
Mama Lil’s Mildly Spicy Peppers are a unique and delicious way to spice up your meals and give them a flavor from which you can truly benefit.

These peppers have just the right amount of heat without being overwhelming—and since they come in a 26.5-ounce jar, there will be plenty left over after your next party!

These peppers from Mama Lil’s are ideal for those who like a bit of heat but don’t want too much burn in their food.

The mild flavor makes them great for adding to salads or as an accompaniment to any dish that needs an extra zing of flavor without being overwhelming.

OH SNAP! Pickling Co. Dilly Bites – 3.25 fl oz, 12-count

Are you ready for a seriously crunchy and totally craveable snacking experience? OH SNAP! Pickling Co. has cooked up something that will have you shouting, “oh snap!” – Dilly Bites!

oh snap pickling co dilly bites
Oh Snap! Pickling Co. Dilly Bites are a tasty and fun way to add delicious flavor to your meals.

These fresh dill pickle slices are brilliantly seasoned for a great taste. And unlike other pickle snacks, Dilly Bites come with no brine added for less mess.

But the convenience doesn’t stop there. Each 3.25 fl oz single-serve pouch is ideal for throwing in your bag to take on the go, making it easier than ever to satisfy those pickle cravings while keeping it healthy and full of flavor.

Plus, they’re Keto-friendly, Vegan, Non-GMO, fat-free, gluten-free, and Kosher – so you can truly enjoy yourself without sacrificing taste!

Add a little extra crunch to your snack routine today with OH SNAP!’s Dilly Bites – just make sure to keep them refrigerated after each use.

Famous Dave’s Signature Spicy Pickle Chips – 64 fl oz

Are you looking for something truly unique and different to spice up your next meal or snack? Famous Dave’s Signature Spicy Pickle Chips provide just the right blend of sweetness and heat that will tantalize your taste buds!

famous dave’s signature spicy pickle chips
Famous Dave’s Signature Spicy Pickle Chips are a beloved treat by those with a passion for flavor.

This 64 fl oz (2 qt) 1.89 L jar of pickle chips, made in a fresh pack, is sure to become your favorite go-to condiment.

First, tangy dill pickles are fried in a delicious batter to crisp golden perfection. Then they are coated with a unique Signature Spicy seasoning blend – with just the perfect amount of crunch and flavor.

Add them to sandwiches, burgers, salads, and more for an extraordinary burst of taste. And when you’re done, simply refrigerate the unused portion for later – so simple yet so delicious!

Pleasant Valley 3/16″ Cut Old Fashioned Kosher Dill Pickle Chips – 1 Gallon

Introducing Pleasant Valley’s delicious Old-Fashioned Kosher Dill Pickle Chips. Get ready to enjoy the classic flavor of crunchy, tangy pickles with a timeless twist.

pleasant valley 3/16" cut old fashioned kosher dill pickle chips
Pleasant Valley 3/16″ Cut Old Fashioned Kosher Dill Pickle Chips are a great way to add a delicious, tangy crunch to your favorite foods.

These chips are made from only the freshest and finest ingredients and crafted with traditional techniques that give them an unmistakable dill taste.

The ideal accompaniment for any sandwich or snacking occasion, these 3/16″ krinkle cut chips will make you and your taste buds happy! Plus, they’re conveniently packaged in a 1 Gallon jar, so you’ll never run out!

Delight in every bite with an authentic old-fashioned flavor – they’re sure to be your next favorite pickle. Not only do they have a delightful flavor, but these chips are also Kosher certified and contain no artificial preservatives or trans fats.

And because they stand up to the test of time like your grandparent’s favorite recipe, you can rest assured knowing every bite is fresh and full of unique texture for a satisfying crunch that compliments any meal.

This jar of zesty dills packs quite a tasty punch – you won’t find better pickles around!

Van Holten’s Pickle In-A-Pouch Sour Sis – 7.5 oz, 12 ct

If you’re looking for a lip-smacking pickle adventure, Van Holten’s Pickle In-A-Pouch Sour Sis is an excellent pick!

van holten's pickle in-a-pouch sour sis
Van Holten’s Pickle In-A-Pouch Sour Sis brings an innovative twist to the classic sour dill pickle.

Each pickle is individually packaged in its own 7.5-oz pouch, ensuring each sour and tangy bite packs a powerful punch.

With twelve packages per box, you never have to worry about not having enough pickles again!

Ideal for parties, picnics, and snacks on the go, Van Holten’s Pickle In-A-Pouch Sour Sis can even be enjoyed without refrigeration!

Also, this product is kosher and gluten-free, so everyone can enjoy it. Get your hands on a box today, and let the tart and tangy party begin!

Olive Kosher Dill Pickles – 1 Gallon

Last but not least is Mt Olive Kosher Dill Pickles, which come in an enormous 1-gallon jug that will keep even the biggest dill fans satisfied for months!

mt olive kosher dill pickles
Mt. Olive Kosher Dill Pickles offer a delicious and savory flavor that will make your homemade dishes stand out.

For those who like their pickles extra crispy and flavorful, Mt Olive Kosher Dill Pickles are the way to go!

The brine is packed with herbs and spices that give these pickles their signature sharp taste without being overly salty or sour.

Not only are these pickles crunchy and full of flavor, but they also contain no artificial ingredients, so you can feel good about eating them too!

How Much Do Costco’s Pickles Cost?

If you are trying to figure out how much Costco’s pickles cost, you will be pleased to know that the price depends on a variety of factors.

The size of the jar, type of pickle, and even location will all play a role in determining the final cost.

Furthermore, their prices are known for being competitive and offering good value for your money when it comes to their selection of pickles.

If you want to take some of the guessings out of it, the best option is to look online for more information regarding pricing at your local store.

This way, you can be confident that you are making an informed decision when it comes to buying pickles from Costco.

How Long Do Costco Pickles Last?

If you love Costco pickles, one of the most incredible things about them is that they last a long time.

Costo’s selection of jarred pickles is among the best out there, offering a delicious and crunchy snack that lasts for weeks or even months in your refrigerator.

In fact, when stored in an airtight container or jar in the refrigerator, Costco pickles can typically stay fresh for up to two years. This allows individuals and families to stock up on these tasty treats without worrying about them going to waste.

However, it’s important to remember that once the pickles are opened from their original packaging, their lifespan diminishes significantly.

This means that the best way to ensure they remain at peak quality is to enjoy a few pickles at a time and be sure to store any remaining ones properly.

While most shops sell smaller-sized jars of pickles, Costco offers jumbo containers that hold an abundant amount of this hearty snack.

How Do I Store My Pickles From Costco?

Figuring out how to store your pickles from Costco may seem overwhelming, but there are easy and effective ways to keep them fresh.

The key is to maintain their moisture content. Start by checking the expiration or best-by dates on the jar. By doing this, you can make sure that you prioritize eating your pickles sooner rather than later.

Before storing, be sure to give the jar a quick rinse with cold water and mild dish soap.

Once opened, be sure to tightly seal the lid and store it on a dark refrigerator shelf with other condiments such as mustard and ketchup. Burying the jar at the back of your fridge also helps!

Storing your Costco pickles properly is essential to prevent spoilage and maintain their flavor.

To ensure optimal pickle longevity, store them in an airtight container in the refrigerator. This will help to preserve the crunchy texture and delicious taste of the pickles by ensuring they do not get exposed to air or other room-temperature elements that can cause rotting or mold growth.

Keeping them in a refrigerator is a good idea as long as you are able to transfer them into a secure container without compromising their quality.

Make sure not to store pickles near smelly items such as raw onions or garlic, as these fragrances can easily transfer to other foods!

When it comes time to dispose of your pickle jar, do your part to protect the environment by placing it in the recycle bin.

What Is The Best Way To Eat Costco Pickles?

Eating Costco pickles is an unforgettable experience. They are big and juicy, making every bite an explosion of flavor.

The best way to enjoy them is to use a fork or knife, cut off one slice at a time, and savor the taste with every bite.

Holding a pickle in your hand and taking bites allows you to get the full spectrum of flavors from each slice, bringing out the crunchiness and juiciness in the pickle that gives it its unique flavor profile.

Pickle lovers should never forget about the power of condiments; adding mustard, mayonnaise, onion powder, or other condiments can take your Costco pickle experience to new heights.

Enjoying Costco pickles adds a bit of class to any meal or snack time!

PB&J Sandwich With Pickles Recipe

When it comes to enjoying Costco-bought pickles, there are limitless possibilities.

One of the most delicious ways to enjoy them is by making a classic PB&J sandwich with not just any kind of bread but a freshly baked pain au levain that can be found in the bakery section of your nearest Costco store.

Put generous amounts of peanut butter and jelly between two pieces of bread and top it off with juicy slices of dill pickle to get the perfect balance of savory and sweet flavors.

The crunchy yet smooth texture of the pickles is the cherry on top that makes this classic lunchtime meal even more exciting. Just make sure they are cold!

Classic BLT Sandwich With Dill Pickles

One of the best ways to enjoy Costco’s pickles is to eat them as part of a great sandwich.

Adding slices of the crunchy dill pickle to a classic BLT, for instance, is sure to give your sandwich the added “zing” you are looking for!

Furthermore, with the size and texture of Costco’s pickles, cutting them into small cubes or even slicing them julienne-style provides creative possibilities that most store-bought pickles just can’t match.

All in all, Costco’s pickles should not be limited to subsisting on their own – incorporate them in a meal for an even more pleasant eating experience.

What Are Some Tips For Picking The Best Pickles At Costco?

When trying to pick the best pickles available at Costco, it’s important to consider both taste and crunch.

The right pickle can be a great addition to a meal or snack, so selecting wisely is key. Taste testing is one of the best ways to determine which type of pickle suits your palate best. If they smell too pungent, pass!

If you like spicy pickles, always check the label for the spice level and make sure it meets your standards.

If you’re looking for an especially crunchy pickle, pressing down on each cucumber in the jar will give you an indication as to whether it meets your expectations.

Choose pickles made with cucumbers that boast firm skin and minimal scarring to ensure the produce in your pickle is of quality.

Check the color of the pickles – a vibrant green usually indicates freshness.

Additionally, make sure you take a look at the ingredients list and expiration date before making your purchase if health and food safety are important considerations. Doing so will help to ensure that you get the freshest and tastiest pickles possible.

Furthermore, it’s important to consider size and shape. Costco offers a wide array of pickle varieties, from bubbled-ended gherkins to cucumber slices, so think about the consistency you prefer.

Also, pay attention to the type of pickling process. Are they brined in vinegar or fermented with natural bacteria? This will determine their flavor profile and whether you get that classic tangy bite or something more mellow and sour.

Moreover, beware of any pickles that seem mushy or have an unnatural smell – these could be signs of infestation from bacterial or fungal contamination.

Lastly, be mindful of your own personal preferences, such as fermentation time or ingredients added for flavoring.

Enjoying pickles is ultimately based on what you like, so make sure to use your taste buds to select your perfect slice!

Conclusion

The next time you find yourself wondering which pickles to buy when shopping at Costco, look no further than this comprehensive guide!

From classic favorites like Grillo’s Italian Dill Spears or Nalley’s Whole Baby Dills to more eclectic options like Princess Pickled Asparagus or Mama Lil’s Mildly Spicy Peppers—there’s something here for every taste bud!

So don’t forget to add some of these delicious picks from our list when stocking up on groceries next time you’re shopping at Costco!

Sunny Hoi

Sunny Hoi

Sunny is an experienced content strategist. He has a deep understanding of the retail and finance industries. Sunny has written extensively about products, services, stores, stocks, cryptocurrencies, and investment strategies. Sunny's writing reflects his deep understanding of his subjects and commitment to providing clear, concise information that helps readers make informed decisions.

Wealthy Magnate
Logo